Ad Spot

Editorial: Balloons not all hot air

The continuing saga of the Chinese spy balloon points to some real security issues, but also highlights just how much other stuff is in the sky.

Oh, the humanity! Not since the fiery demise of the Hindenburg has a balloon so dominated a news cycle.

The saga of what the Pentagon has identified as a wandering Chinese spy balloon is continuing to play out. There are serious matters of national security involved, although just how serious either the U.S. government doesn’t yet know or isn’t telling. It’s not even entirely clear what the Chinese government hopes to learn from its balloon program that it couldn’t learn with spy satellites. We do know a balloon, in theory, could lurk over a target for a longer period of time than a satellite. But U.S. military officials have expressed skepticism of its real intelligence value.

“We did not assess that it presented a significant collection hazard beyond what already exists in actionable technical means from the Chinese,” according to Gen. Glenn VanHerck, the commander of U.S. Northern Command and NORAD.

The Biden administration’s decision to let the balloon pass over the U.S. and shoot it down after it was over the Atlantic has resulted in a lot of Monday morning quarterbacking, most of it little but political posturing.

Shooting the balloon down over water has made it possible for the U.S. government to recover more of it intact. This may turn out to be a much larger intelligence screw-up for the Chinese government than for us.

Nevertheless, the Biden administration seems to have heard its critics and reacted — by overreacting.

In the week since the Chinese balloon’s voyage, North American air defense systems have been re-tuned. As a result, they’re now picking up more “unidentified flying objects” than they were before, and U.S. fighter planes have shot down at least three more of them to date.

Are they yet more spy balloons? Probably not.

“We don’t see anything that points right now to being part of the PRC spy balloon program,” White House national security spokesman John Kirby told reporters, referring to the People’s Republic of China, on Tuesday. It’s also not likely the objects were “intelligence collection against the United States of any kind — that’s the indication now.”

According to The Associated Press, “Little is known about the three objects shot down over three successive days, from Friday to Sunday, in part because it’s been challenging to recover debris from remote locations in the Canadian Yukon, off northern Alaska and near the Upper Peninsula of Michigan on Lake Huron. So far, officials have no indication they were part of a bigger surveillance operation along with the balloon that that was shot down off the South Carolina coast on Feb. 4.”

So what are they? Lost weather balloons? Forgotten science experiments? Possibly, maybe even likely.

This all put a new spin on last year’s congressional hearing on “unidentified aerial phenomena,” the government’s new, less sensational term for UFOs.

Scott W. Bray, the deputy director of Naval intelligence, told lawmakers that reports of UAPs have been increasing for a variety of reasons, including improved sensors, an increase in drones and other non-military unmanned aircraft, and “aerial clutter” such as Mylar balloons.

Yes, your lost birthday balloons could end up on the government’s radar — literally.

Officials, then as now, were worried about the UAPs they couldn’t explain not because they thought they were part of an alien visitation, but because hidden among them could be things like China’s balloon — or possibly something with a more dangerous cargo.

China’s balloon isn’t a wake-up call. The U.S. government has been telling us about the real issues and potential threats for a while. It’s just that people would rather talk about aliens from space.

Liberty Middle School

Liberty aces regionals, heads to Science Bowl national finals

Digital Version

The Madison Record digital version – March 29, 2023

Huntsville

Local hockey team in Denver today for USA Hockey National Championships

Events

Camp Invention’s summer STEM program coming to Midtown Elementary

Huntsville

Huntsville Police officer killed, one critically injured in shooting

Bob Jones High School

Bob Jones falls in matchup between two of the top teams in Class 7A

Bob Jones High School

Bob Jones Science Challenge instills young students’ STEM respect

Events

Madison Community Band to present “An American Spring” concert on April 4, kicks off its 30th anniversary celebration

James Clemens High School

Markowitz’s scholarship leads to Germany for 3 weeks

Madison

Cummings reappointed to school board, more questions arise over city manager issue

James Clemens High School

Jets use strong pitching and patience at the plate to overpower Charles Henderson, 12-2

Harvest

Lions screen eyesight for Second Mile Preschool

Harvest

Partnership’s Town Hall to identify treatment choices, locations

Huntsville

Flag flown over US Capitol in honor of Harvest WWII veteran’s 105th birthday

Bob Jones High School

Patriots thrash Winfield City 11-0 in Saturday double-header, plus score wins over Cullman and Buckhorn

James Clemens High School

Jets handle Tennessee teams in comfortable setting of Toyota Field

Madison

‘Spring into fitness’ with ‘bud-dy’ plan at Hogan Family YMCA

Bob Jones High School

Bob Jones HOSA gain 21 berths to international conference

Huntsville

Fantasy Playhouse Children’s Theater & Academy’s conducts regional search to fill education director position 

Huntsville

Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals orders new trial of Huntsville cop William Darby’s murder verdict

Huntsville

Chargers welcome No. 12 West Georgia for three game series

Huntsville

Battle, Strong respond to Washington Post claims Space Command likely to stay in Colorado

Huntsville

No. 7 UAH back at Charger Park for three-game GSC series Saturday and Sunday

Huntsville

Huntsville approves architectural contract for Hays Farm Central Park

x