Letter to the Editor: A city manager would not be a good move for Madison, and here is why

Editor’s note: The following is a letter to the editor addressing the upcoming May 9 special election and city manager issue. The views expressed in all letters to the editor and editorials in The Madison Record do not necessarily express the views of The Record. To submit a letter to the editor, email john@themadisonrecord.com. We reserve the right to edit all submission for space considerations in the paper and content.

Dear Editor,

I am a mom and small business owner here in Madison. I would like to offer a positive vision for government, and why a city manager is not a good move for the city of Madison.

City government should protect our God-given right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. “Happiness” does not mean consumer goods and pleasure. It means we have a right to work hard, create businesses for ourselves, and form homes, families, and churches. We don’t want to “own nothing and be happy.” We want to own homes and businesses. The government’s mission should be to protect these freedoms. Our officials should work hard to protect our rights to own property, and to buy, and sell, and go places. Madison could be a place where its citizens are known for their innovation. Where there are creative small businesses. We don’t need politicians and bureaucrats to plan that–we need them to protect our freedom to do it ourselves.

Sadly, what I see are barriers. We have centralized planning and government-run economic development, right here in Madison. The city seems to be preferring big developers and big chain businesses. Everything feels big now, and it feels like local citizens are getting smaller and smaller.

I do not see that having a city manager would increase our creative local opportunities, and it reduces our voice in local government. Here’s why. The council-manager form of government would give us an unelected city manager. The mayor would no longer run the city and would lose the power to veto the city council. So, citizens would lose a lot of say in city government.

Advocates say that the city manager would run the city like a business. But the city is not a business that has to attract customers—it is a government. It can acquire property under eminent domain. It has the right to use force against us if we fail to pay fees and taxes. That is not a business model! Small business can’t compete with that.

Insulating the city manager from voters so we have less of a voice in that power structure will not help us. We need to keep the government accountable, and make sure it guards our rights. I believe that keeping our current form of government will enable us to guard our rights better than we could if we changed to the council-manager form. I will be voting NO on the city manager on May 9.

Sincerely,
Elizabeth Nemati
Citizen of Madison

Madison

Chess league honors Epling as ‘Coach of the Year’

Harvest

Luna Koi to bring its vibe to ‘Sounds of Summer’

Bob Jones High School

Seeing students as rewards, Word selected Midtown’s ‘Teacher of the Year’

Huntsville

Pre-K Center selects Parameswaran as top teacher

Discovery Middle School

Robotics team, Say Watt!?!, takes FIRST LEGO awards in California

Harvest

TARCOG lands $1.5-million grant from EPA for cleanup

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Mental Skills Coach Assists Team To National Championship Game- Roger Kitchen Builds Character

Bob Jones High School

Journey welcomes Ben Smith as Assistant Principal, Athletic Director

Madison

Chandrakasem, Koswoski excel in DAR essay contests

Harvest

American Legion, VFW to retire flags on Flag Day

Madison

Stundtner proves skills as Midtown’s ‘Staff Member of the Year’

James Clemens High School

Guo, Mysore, Saha dominate awards at regional, state science fairs

Harvest

Madison Hospital names Brandon Jones ‘Employee of the Year’

Bob Jones High School

MCS to present ‘Youth Mental Health First Aid’ sessions

Digital Version

Digital version of The Madison Record – June 12, 2024

Events

Annual Juneteenth Festival returns to Big Spring Park Saturday

Bob Jones High School

Braden Booth Named Mr. Baseball, Super All-State, Class 7A All-State

Harvest

Low-key races (on foot and couch) pivotal for Rotary’s ‘Parrots 0.5K’

Bob Jones High School

Mill Creek names Deberry as outstanding staff employee

Bob Jones High School

Madison Public Library readies for Summer Reading experience

James Clemens High School

Moore honored as ‘Staff Member of the Year’ at James Clemens

Harvest

Madison City Community Orchestra to honor D-Day’s 80th anniversary

Digital Version

Digital version of The Madison Record – June 5, 2024

Madison

Rotary Club awards city employees Hall, Overman and Watson

x