Madison woman shot and killed by police struggled with mental illness

BY ANNA DURRETT / REPORTER

Court documents show the woman shot and killed by Madison police early Saturday morning had a history of mental illness. Madison police shot and killed the woman when she pointed a handgun at them, according to the Madison City Police Department.

Madison resident Deborah Jo Day, 55, was shot outside, near her home in the 100 block of Michael Avenue. Day was transported to Huntsville Hospital where she later died, according to Madison police.

The Madison County 911 Center received multiple calls at approximately 3:49 a.m. about a white woman with a handgun walking on Michael Avenue threatening to shoot her neighbors.

Madison police arrived at the scene and made repeated demands for Day to drop her weapon. Day proceeded to raise the gun toward the officers and she was shot by police.

The Madison County Sheriff’s Office is investigating the incident. The Madison City Police Department is conducting an internal review. The officers involved in the shooting have been placed on administrative leave. No officers were injured.

Day had a history of mental illness, including schizoaffective disorder, according to Madison County court documents from 2004.

Day was arrested for writing five fraudulent checks in 2003 to supermarkets, including checks to Food World, Star Market and Bruno’s. The bad check with the highest amount was to Star Market for $262.06.

She previously was arrested in 2002 for the fraudulent use of a Sears credit card she obtained in her ex-husband’s name.

A court-ordered evaluation of Day by Dr. Randal Burleson was conducted on June 30, 2004, in order to see if she was competent to stand trial for credit card fraud. Burleson found Day competent for trial.

The evaluation states Day said she was first diagnosed with a mental illness in 1993 or 1994. She said she was seen briefly at the Mental Health Center of Madison County and had been seen there consistently since 1998.

The document shows Day lived in Virginia between 1994 and 1996, where she was briefly hospitalized and diagnosed as having depression, delusional disorder and paranoid personality disorder.

Due to mental illness and dangerous behavior in August 2002, Day was involuntarily committed to Huntsville Hospital and then North Alabama Regional Hospital in Decatur, according to the document.

In the evaluation Day said she was taking two milligrams of the anti-psychotic medicine Risperdal for schizoaffective disorder at the time.

Burleson wrote about schizoaffective disorder in his report. “This is a severe psychiatric disorder that involves periods of psychosis and periods, sometimes concurrent, of extreme moods. People who have this disorder often exhibit poor judgment.”

Day had additional altercations with the law in the local area, including disorderly conduct, in which she allegedly threatened the lives of some of her co-workers, resisting arrest, a child custody dispute, and a pet custody dispute.

The evaluation by Burleson shows Day said she grew up in Virginia as the sixth of 11 children. She said she studied political science at the University of Alabama in Huntsville for three years and accounting at the National Career College in Huntsville.

Day said she did office and restaurant work mostly until she began receiving disability payments due to mental illness around late 2002 or early 2003.

According to Day, she had two children and had been married three times. She said her oldest child had been adopted and her mother raised her youngest child.

Madison

Police department’s ‘Rape, Aggression, Defense’ class open to women

Harvest

Cheery Loops Crochet brings appealing designs to Madison Street Festival

Madison

Madison History Association to learn about ‘Hughes-Anderson Connection’

Bob Jones High School

Patriots rebound with 50-23 rout of Grissom

James Clemens High School

Huntsville dusted by Jets who stay perfect

Bob Jones High School

Bands to converge on Madison for Rocket City Marching Invitational

Madison

Register now for Fall Scholars, Bughouse tourneys

Bob Jones High School

Dauma transforms South & Pine to include Blue Apple Books

Harvest

Columbia JROTC carwash to buy uniform basics

Madison

Dr. Nichols releases video message addressing parents’ concerns over school threats

Madison

Madison City Schools increased police presence today in response to “unsubstantiated” threats

Bob Jones High School

Chess players open season with Summer Knights tourney

Madison

Heritage Harmony Club promises more than just singing

Bob Jones High School

Immaculately landscaped sites earn Beautification Awards

Bob Jones High School

Local teens rep Madison at Boys State, Girls State

Bob Jones High School

Lady Patriots win Tournament of Champions at Supreme Courts

Madison

Limestone sheriff: Madison man charged with child and animal abuse

Madison

Volleyball Roundup: James Clemens, Sparkman and Madison Academy

FRONT PAGE FEATURED

Jameen Mathews Races To Bronze Medal At World Meet Held In Sweden

Madison

Chamber announces Board of Directors nominees

Bob Jones High School

Nominate alum, service candidate for Bob Jones Hall of Fame

Bob Jones High School

MADISON BOWL – Jets slam the door on Bob Jones with field goal block in epic game

Madison

Alabama High School Football Scores – September 6, 2024

Harvest

Sparkman rallies in fourth quarter, but unable to overcome blocked field goal in overtime

x